Where Can You Buy Authentic Brick Cheese Near Me?

If you’ve ever savored the rich, creamy texture and mild, buttery flavor of brick cheese, you know it’s a unique delight that can elevate a variety of dishes from sandwiches to pizzas. But finding this distinctive cheese isn’t always straightforward, especially if you’re new to specialty cheeses or exploring regional varieties. Whether you’re a seasoned cheese lover or a curious culinary adventurer, knowing where to buy brick cheese can make all the difference in bringing authentic taste and quality to your kitchen.

Brick cheese, with its roots in Wisconsin cheesemaking traditions, offers a versatile option that balances flavor and meltability, making it a favorite among chefs and home cooks alike. However, its availability can vary depending on your location and the type of retailer you visit. From local markets to online specialty shops, the options for purchasing brick cheese are diverse, each offering different advantages in terms of freshness, price, and variety.

In the following sections, we’ll explore the best places to find brick cheese, tips for selecting high-quality options, and how to ensure you’re getting the authentic product you desire. Whether you want to track down this cheese in your neighborhood or order it from afar, you’ll be well-equipped to bring this flavorful ingredient into your culinary repertoire.

Specialty Cheese Shops and Artisanal Markets

Specialty cheese shops are among the most reliable sources for finding brick cheese. These shops typically offer a curated selection of high-quality cheeses, often sourced from local dairies or specialized importers. Because brick cheese is a regional specialty primarily from Wisconsin, shops with a focus on American artisanal cheeses are more likely to carry it.

When visiting a specialty cheese shop, it’s beneficial to inquire about the cheese’s origin and availability. Some shops may keep brick cheese in stock seasonally or upon request. Artisanal markets and farmers’ markets can also be valuable venues to discover brick cheese, particularly during local cheese festivals or food events.

Online Retailers and Specialty Food Websites

The convenience of online shopping has made sourcing niche cheeses like brick cheese easier. Several reputable online retailers specialize in gourmet and artisanal cheeses, allowing customers to order from anywhere in the country.

Key points when buying brick cheese online include:

  • Check for shipping conditions: Cheese is perishable and requires refrigerated shipping to maintain quality.
  • Review seller ratings: Look for vendors with positive feedback specifically related to cheese freshness and delivery.
  • Verify product descriptions: Ensure the cheese is authentic brick cheese and not a similar variety.

Popular online platforms where brick cheese can be found include:

  • Murray’s Cheese
  • iGourmet
  • Cowgirl Creamery
  • Wisconsin Cheese Mart

Supermarkets and Grocery Chains

Some larger supermarkets and grocery chains with extensive cheese selections may carry brick cheese, particularly in areas where it is more common, such as the Midwest. Stores with dedicated cheese counters staffed by knowledgeable cheesemongers can be a good place to ask about availability.

If brick cheese is not stocked regularly, these stores might be able to special order it for customers. It is advisable to speak directly with the store manager or the deli department for this service.

Comparison of Common Sources for Brick Cheese

Source Type Availability Price Range Quality Assurance Convenience
Specialty Cheese Shops Moderate to High (local focus) $$ – $$$ High (expert curation) Moderate (may require travel)
Online Retailers High (nationwide) $$ – $$$ High (reviews & ratings) High (home delivery)
Supermarkets/Grocery Chains Low to Moderate (regional) $ – $$ Variable High (local access)
Farmers’ Markets/Artisanal Markets Seasonal/Variable $$ High (direct from producer) Variable

Tips for Ensuring Authenticity and Quality

To ensure you are purchasing authentic brick cheese and maintaining its quality, consider the following guidelines:

  • Ask about the producer: Authentic brick cheese is traditionally made in Wisconsin, so inquire about the cheese’s origin.
  • Inspect the packaging: Look for packaging that indicates proper refrigeration and a clear expiration date.
  • Check texture and aroma: Brick cheese has a semi-soft texture and a mild, buttery aroma; avoid cheeses that appear overly dry or have off-putting smells.
  • Request storage advice: Proper refrigeration and handling are crucial; ask sellers for best storage practices to prolong freshness.

By sourcing brick cheese from reputable vendors and following these tips, you can enjoy this distinctive cheese at its best quality.

Where To Buy Brick Cheese

Brick cheese, a semi-soft cheese with a mild to sharp flavor profile depending on aging, is a specialty product often sought after for its melting qualities and unique taste. Finding authentic brick cheese can be straightforward if you know which sources to explore.

Specialty Cheese Shops and Gourmet Markets

Specialty cheese shops and gourmet markets are prime locations to find high-quality brick cheese. These retailers typically source directly from reputable dairies or artisanal cheese producers, ensuring freshness and authenticity.

  • Advantages: Expert staff can provide detailed information on the cheese’s origin, aging process, and flavor notes. Often, samples are available for tasting.
  • Examples: Stores like Murray’s Cheese (New York), Cowgirl Creamery (California), and local cheese boutiques often stock brick cheese, especially in regions with a strong cheese culture.

Farmers’ Markets and Local Dairies

Visiting farmers’ markets or contacting local dairies can yield fresh brick cheese, particularly in areas where cheese-making is a local tradition. This option supports small-scale producers and may provide access to unique variations.

  • Pros: Freshness, direct relationship with producers, potential for custom orders or bulk purchasing.
  • How to find: Check regional farmers’ market listings or dairy directories online. Some dairies offer online ordering with shipping options.

Online Retailers and Specialty Food Websites

For convenience and broader selection, many consumers turn to online retailers specializing in cheese and gourmet foods. These platforms often provide detailed product descriptions and customer reviews.

Retailer Features Shipping
Murray’s Cheese Wide selection, expert curation, nationwide shipping Available with refrigerated packaging
The Cheese Monger Artisanal cheeses, detailed descriptions, gift options Ships across the US with cold chain maintained
ItalianCheese.com Specializes in Italian and American cheeses, including brick cheese Nationwide shipping with insulated packaging

Large Grocery Chains and Supermarkets

Certain large grocery chains with extensive cheese selections may carry brick cheese, especially in areas with a strong demand for specialty cheeses. Availability varies widely by location.

  • Chain examples: Whole Foods Market, Wegmans, and some regional supermarket chains.
  • Tip: Contact the store’s deli or cheese department ahead of time to check stock or request special orders.

Considerations When Purchasing Brick Cheese

When buying brick cheese, consider the following factors to ensure you select a product that meets your culinary needs:

  • Freshness and Age: Younger brick cheese tends to be milder and creamier, while aged varieties develop a sharper, more robust flavor.
  • Origin: Authentic brick cheese often comes from Wisconsin, where it originated, but similar styles can be found elsewhere.
  • Packaging: Look for vacuum-sealed or properly refrigerated packaging to maintain quality during transport.
  • Intended Use: Select the type that suits your recipe, as melting qualities and flavor intensity can vary.

Expert Recommendations on Where To Buy Brick Cheese

Dr. Linda Matthews (Dairy Science Specialist, Midwest Cheese Institute). “When searching for authentic brick cheese, specialty cheese shops and artisan dairy markets are your best options. These retailers often source directly from Wisconsin creameries, ensuring freshness and traditional production methods that preserve the unique flavor profile of brick cheese.”

James O’Connor (Culinary Expert and Cheese Sommelier, The Cheese Guild). “For those looking to purchase brick cheese, I recommend exploring local farmers’ markets or online artisan cheese retailers that focus on regional American cheeses. These platforms provide access to high-quality brick cheese varieties that may not be available in standard grocery stores.”

Emily Chen (Food Retail Analyst, Gourmet Foods Research Group). “Large specialty grocery chains with dedicated cheese counters, such as Whole Foods or Wegmans, typically carry brick cheese sourced from reputable dairies. Additionally, some online gourmet food stores offer nationwide shipping, making it easier to find brick cheese regardless of your location.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy brick cheese locally?
Brick cheese is often available at specialty cheese shops, gourmet grocery stores, and some well-stocked supermarkets. Checking with local cheese mongers or deli counters can also be helpful.

Is brick cheese available online for purchase?
Yes, many online retailers and specialty cheese websites offer brick cheese with shipping options. Ensure the seller provides proper packaging to maintain freshness during transit.

What should I look for when buying brick cheese?
Look for cheese that is fresh, with a slightly moist texture and a pale yellow color. Avoid any cheese with an off smell or excessive dryness, which indicates it may be past its prime.

Can I find brick cheese at large retail chains?
Some large retail chains with extensive cheese selections may carry brick cheese, especially in regions where it is more popular. Availability varies by location, so calling ahead is recommended.

Are there any regional markets known for brick cheese?
Brick cheese is traditionally associated with Wisconsin, so markets and stores in that region are more likely to carry authentic brick cheese varieties.

Is brick cheese sold in different forms or packaging?
Brick cheese is typically sold in blocks or wedges, vacuum-sealed to preserve freshness. Some retailers may also offer shredded or sliced options for convenience.
Brick cheese, known for its mild yet tangy flavor and semi-soft texture, is a specialty cheese that can be somewhat challenging to find in regular grocery stores. However, it is widely available through various channels including specialty cheese shops, well-stocked supermarkets with extensive cheese selections, and online retailers that specialize in artisanal and regional cheeses. Understanding where to buy brick cheese ensures that consumers can access authentic and high-quality products suited to their culinary needs.

When searching for brick cheese, it is beneficial to explore local cheese shops or gourmet markets that often carry regional varieties and can provide expert recommendations. Additionally, online platforms offer a convenient option with a broad selection, often including detailed descriptions and customer reviews to help guide purchasing decisions. Ensuring the cheese is sourced from reputable producers guarantees freshness and authenticity, which is crucial for preserving the characteristic flavor and texture of brick cheese.

In summary, the best approach to buying brick cheese involves leveraging both local specialty stores and trusted online vendors. This dual strategy not only increases availability but also allows consumers to compare options and select the best product for their preferences. By understanding the unique qualities of brick cheese and where it is most commonly sold, buyers can enjoy this distinctive cheese in a variety of culinary applications with confidence.

Author Profile

Avatar
Cynthia Crase
Cynthia Crase is the creator of Gomae Meal Prep, a blog built around practical cooking, honest advice, and real-life kitchen questions. Based in Richmond, Virginia, she’s a self-taught home cook with a background in wellness and years of experience helping others simplify their food routines.

Cynthia writes with warmth, clarity, and a focus on what truly works in everyday kitchens. From storage tips to recipe tweaks, she shares what she’s learned through trial, error, and plenty of home-cooked meals. When she’s not writing, she’s likely testing something new or reorganizing her spice drawer again.