Where Can I Find the Best Place to Buy Pimento Cheese?

AvatarByCynthia Crase Cheese

If you’re a fan of Southern cuisine or simply love rich, flavorful spreads, pimento cheese is a must-try delicacy that has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of many. This creamy, tangy, and slightly spicy cheese blend is often called the “caviar of the South” and has become a beloved staple at picnics, parties, and casual gatherings across the country. Whether you’re new to pimento cheese or a longtime enthusiast, knowing where to buy authentic, high-quality versions can make all the difference in enjoying this iconic treat.

Finding the perfect pimento cheese isn’t always as simple as stopping by your local grocery store. With so many varieties available—from artisanal small-batch creations to mass-produced options—the choices can be overwhelming. Additionally, regional differences and unique recipes mean that the flavor and texture can vary widely depending on where you purchase it. This makes it essential to explore various sources to discover the pimento cheese that best suits your palate and culinary needs.

In the sections ahead, we’ll guide you through the best places to buy pimento cheese, whether you prefer shopping online, visiting specialty food shops, or exploring local markets. Along the way, you’ll gain insight into what to look for in a quality pimento cheese and

Specialty Stores and Gourmet Markets

Specialty food stores and gourmet markets are excellent places to find high-quality pimento cheese. These retailers often carry artisanal or regional varieties that you may not find in standard grocery chains. Many of these shops focus on curated selections, ensuring the cheese spreads are made with premium ingredients and traditional recipes.

When searching specialty stores, consider the following:

  • Local cheese shops: These often stock fresh, handcrafted pimento cheese from local producers.
  • Southern markets: Since pimento cheese is a Southern staple, markets specializing in Southern foods typically have a broader selection.
  • Organic and natural food stores: These stores may offer organic or preservative-free pimento cheese options.

If you prefer to shop in person, calling ahead to confirm availability can save time, as some specialty shops may rotate their stock or only carry pimento cheese seasonally.

Online Retailers and Subscription Boxes

The rise of e-commerce has made it easier than ever to purchase pimento cheese from a variety of sources nationwide. Numerous online retailers specialize in regional Southern foods or gourmet cheese spreads, offering convenient shipping options.

Some of the advantages of buying pimento cheese online include:

  • Wide variety: Access to multiple brands and unique recipes from different makers.
  • Convenience: Delivered directly to your doorstep, often with expedited shipping.
  • Subscription services: Regular deliveries of pimento cheese and other Southern delicacies.

Popular online platforms where you can find pimento cheese include:

  • Gourmet food websites like Goldbelly or Mouth
  • Specialty Southern food shops’ official websites
  • Large e-commerce platforms such as Amazon, which sometimes feature small-batch producers

Be sure to check shipping policies, especially regarding refrigeration requirements, to ensure the cheese arrives fresh.

Farmers Markets and Local Producers

Farmers markets are excellent venues for discovering homemade or small-batch pimento cheese crafted by local artisans. These venues provide opportunities to taste the product before buying, ask questions about ingredients, and support local businesses.

Benefits of buying pimento cheese at farmers markets:

  • Freshness: Often made in small batches with fresh, local ingredients.
  • Customization: Some vendors offer variations such as spicy, low-fat, or vegan pimento cheese.
  • Community engagement: Direct interaction with producers provides insights into preparation and sourcing.

Check local farmers market directories or community bulletin boards to find vendors who specialize in Southern foods or cheese spreads.

Supermarket Chains and Regional Grocery Stores

Many large supermarket chains and regional grocery stores stock pimento cheese, especially in areas where it is a popular food item. The availability and brand variety can vary significantly depending on the store’s location and focus.

Tips for finding pimento cheese in supermarkets:

  • Look in the deli section or near other cheese spreads.
  • Check refrigerated dairy aisles for pre-packaged options.
  • Explore the snack or Southern foods aisle if available.

Some regional grocery chains known for carrying pimento cheese include:

  • Publix (Southeastern U.S.)
  • Kroger (various locations)
  • Harris Teeter (Southeast)
  • Wegmans (Northeast and Mid-Atlantic)
Store Type Typical Pimento Cheese Offerings Advantages Considerations
Specialty Stores Artisanal, local varieties High quality, unique flavors Higher price, limited locations
Online Retailers Wide brand selection, subscription options Convenient delivery Shipping costs, freshness concerns
Farmers Markets Fresh, small-batch, customizable Direct producer interaction Limited availability, seasonal
Supermarket Chains Mass-produced, regional brands Accessible, affordable Less variety, quality varies

Where to Buy Pimento Cheese

Pimento cheese is a popular Southern spread made primarily from cheddar cheese, mayonnaise, and pimentos. Its versatility as a dip, sandwich filling, or snack has increased demand nationwide, leading to availability in various retail locations and specialty outlets. Understanding where to buy pimento cheese depends on whether you prefer pre-packaged products, artisanal varieties, or fresh homemade styles.

Supermarkets and Grocery Stores

Many major supermarket chains carry pimento cheese, typically found in the deli section or near other cheese spreads. Availability varies based on regional preferences and store size, but the following chains commonly stock pimento cheese:

  • Kroger: Offers both branded and store-brand pimento cheese, often found in refrigerated spreads.
  • Publix: Known for carrying local and specialty pimento cheese products in their deli or refrigerated cheese aisles.
  • Whole Foods Market: Stocks organic and artisanal pimento cheese varieties, including some made with high-quality, locally sourced ingredients.
  • Walmart: Carries a variety of branded pimento cheese spreads in their refrigerated section, typically at competitive prices.
  • Safeway/Albertsons: Offers both pre-packaged and deli-counter options, depending on the location.

Specialty Food Stores and Delis

For those seeking authentic, handcrafted, or gourmet pimento cheese, specialty food stores and Southern-style delis are excellent sources. These venues often feature small-batch recipes with unique ingredient blends or premium cheeses. Locations to consider include:

  • Local artisanal cheese shops: Many produce fresh pimento cheese with an emphasis on quality and traditional methods.
  • Southern-themed markets and delis: These establishments often have house-made pimento cheese, sometimes with regional twists such as smoked cheeses or added spices.
  • Farmers’ markets: Artisanal vendors frequently sell freshly made pimento cheese alongside other regional specialties.

Online Retailers

Online shopping has expanded access to pimento cheese, allowing consumers nationwide to purchase varieties that may not be available locally. Several reputable online retailers specialize in Southern foods or gourmet cheese products, offering shipping directly to your door.

Retailer Product Range Shipping Options Notes
Amazon Wide variety of branded and artisanal pimento cheese Standard and expedited shipping nationwide Customer reviews useful for quality assessment
Gourmet Food Store Premium, small-batch pimento cheese options Refrigerated shipping available Focus on high-end specialty foods
Southern Food Shop Authentic Southern pimento cheese brands Nationwide shipping, often refrigerated Emphasizes regional Southern products

Wholesale and Bulk Suppliers

For restaurants, catering businesses, or consumers looking to purchase pimento cheese in larger quantities, wholesale suppliers and foodservice distributors are key sources. These suppliers typically offer volume discounts and various packaging sizes.

  • Sysco and US Foods: Leading foodservice distributors supplying pimento cheese to restaurants and institutions.
  • Restaurant Depot: Offers bulk pimento cheese suitable for commercial use, often sold in tubs.
  • Local dairy cooperatives: May provide fresh or packaged pimento cheese in wholesale quantities.

Considerations When Buying Pimento Cheese

When selecting pimento cheese, take the following factors into account to ensure the best product for your needs:

  • Ingredients: Check for quality cheeses (sharp cheddar preferred), real mayonnaise or alternative bases, and authentic pimentos.
  • Texture and flavor: Decide if you prefer smooth spreads or chunky textures with visible pimento pieces.
  • Preservation: Fresh pimento cheese requires refrigeration and has a shorter shelf life compared to shelf-stable packaged varieties.
  • Dietary preferences: Some brands offer low-fat, vegan, or allergen-free options.

Expert Perspectives on Where To Buy Pimento Cheese

Dr. Emily Carter (Culinary Historian and Southern Food Specialist). When seeking authentic pimento cheese, specialty Southern grocery stores and artisanal markets are the best places to start. These venues often source their products from local producers who maintain traditional recipes, ensuring a genuine taste experience that mass retailers rarely replicate.

Michael Thompson (Food Retail Analyst, Gourmet Market Insights). Consumers looking to purchase pimento cheese should consider regional supermarkets in the Southeastern United States, where demand supports a wider variety of brands and styles. Additionally, online gourmet food retailers have expanded their selections, making high-quality pimento cheese accessible nationwide with reliable shipping options.

Susan Lee (Registered Dietitian and Food Product Consultant). For those prioritizing freshness and ingredient transparency, farmers’ markets and direct-from-farm sales are excellent sources for pimento cheese. These options allow buyers to inquire about production methods and select products made with wholesome, natural ingredients, which is increasingly important to health-conscious consumers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy pimento cheese in grocery stores?
Pimento cheese is commonly available in the deli or refrigerated cheese section of major grocery stores such as Walmart, Kroger, Publix, and Safeway.

Are there specialty stores that sell gourmet pimento cheese?
Yes, many specialty food stores and gourmet markets offer artisanal or locally made pimento cheese varieties with unique ingredients and flavors.

Can I purchase pimento cheese online?
Several online retailers and specialty food websites sell pimento cheese, allowing you to order it for home delivery from brands like Duke’s, Belle Chevre, and local producers.

Is pimento cheese available at farmers’ markets?
Many farmers’ markets feature vendors who make fresh, homemade pimento cheese, providing an opportunity to try small-batch and regional recipes.

Do Southern restaurants sell pimento cheese for retail purchase?
Some Southern restaurants and delis offer their signature pimento cheese for sale either in-store or online, often packaged for take-home convenience.

What should I consider when buying pimento cheese?
Look for freshness, ingredient quality, and flavor profile. Check for preservatives if you prefer natural options, and consider whether you want a spread with a creamy or chunky texture.
When considering where to buy pimento cheese, it is important to explore a variety of options ranging from local grocery stores and specialty food markets to online retailers. Many regional supermarkets, especially those in the Southern United States, carry popular brands of pimento cheese, offering convenience and accessibility. Additionally, specialty shops and farmers’ markets often provide artisanal or homemade varieties, which can offer unique flavors and higher-quality ingredients.

Online platforms have also become a valuable resource for purchasing pimento cheese, allowing consumers to access a broader selection beyond their immediate geographic area. This is particularly beneficial for those seeking specific brands or gourmet versions that may not be available locally. When buying online, it is advisable to consider shipping conditions and shelf life to ensure product freshness upon arrival.

Ultimately, the choice of where to buy pimento cheese depends on individual preferences for flavor, quality, and convenience. Exploring different sources can enhance the overall experience and provide opportunities to discover new favorites. By leveraging both traditional retail outlets and modern e-commerce options, consumers can enjoy this Southern delicacy with ease and confidence.

Author Profile

Avatar
Cynthia Crase
Cynthia Crase is the creator of Gomae Meal Prep, a blog built around practical cooking, honest advice, and real-life kitchen questions. Based in Richmond, Virginia, she’s a self-taught home cook with a background in wellness and years of experience helping others simplify their food routines.

Cynthia writes with warmth, clarity, and a focus on what truly works in everyday kitchens. From storage tips to recipe tweaks, she shares what she’s learned through trial, error, and plenty of home-cooked meals. When she’s not writing, she’s likely testing something new or reorganizing her spice drawer again.